#2232 WIP: perf(vk): Threaded rendering's Auto runs the recorder thread from 4 cores, not 6
Commit
Plan (gpt-6.1-terra)
Compare Auto threading on four-core discrete-GPU PCs in Hyrule Field and the Market
⚠️ Note: The model groups permit either operating system and GPU maker, but do not guarantee coverage of both; none of the listed CPUs appears in the current online inventory.
⚠️ Note: Threaded rendering uses its default Auto value because it is not an exposed plan setting; the main-side Auto line is available in its log but cannot be separately enforced by a PR-only expected-log rule.
⚠️ Note: The farm cannot select a power-saving plan or target an unspecified four-core laptop.
In plain words
Compare main and the PR on discrete-GPU PCs with the requested four-core CPU models, using Threaded rendering Auto with no switches. Three starts per build measure 30 seconds each in Hyrule Field and the Market, taking roughly 32 minutes per tester; no matching CPU is currently online, so the targets will wait. The PR fails on a crash, a missing expected Auto-mode log line, a 5% FPS loss, a 10% p99 frame-time increase, or a substantial screenshot difference. Whole-run hitch counts and maximum frame times are reported without limits. No tester online now matches dgpu+cpu-3300x_i3-10100_i3-12100_i3-13100_i7-6700_i7-6700k_i7-7700_i7-7700k, dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200: those targets wait for one.
Asked for
main against this PR, both on Threaded rendering Auto, no switch on either side: this PR changes what Auto picks on CPUs with 4 or 5 physical cores and a discrete GPU, so only those PCs can show a difference. Targets: PCs with a discrete GPU (the dgpu tag) and a CPU of 4 physical cores or fewer, by model. With SMT (4C/8T): i7-6700K, i7-7700K, i7-6700, i7-7700, i3-10100, i3-12100, i3-13100, Ryzen 3 3300X. Without SMT (4C/4T): i5-6500, i5-6600K, i5-7400, i5-7500, i5-7600K, Ryzen 3 1200, 1300X, 3100. An NVIDIA and an AMD card if the testers have them, Windows and Linux both. 2- and 3-core PCs log the same "Auto: off" line on both builds, and 6-core and bigger PCs run both threads on both builds: those compare the same mode. No Steam Deck target here (Auto is off there on both builds: no mirrors). Settings, both sides: frame_rate_cap = 6 (Uncapped), vsync = 2 (Off), frame_generation = 0. Headless is fine (the change is in the replay, not the present path); no window scenario. Scenario: Hyrule Field (HyruleField_Child) measured 30 s, then the Market (Market_Child) measured 30 s in the same start; 3 game starts a side (2 at least). Rules, PR vs main: fps_mean.min_delta_pct = 5 and frametime_p99_ms.max_delta_pct = 10 on each segment, crash = false. Hitch counts (run_hitch_count, run_frametime_max_ms) report-only. Log check on the PR side: "vk: Threaded rendering: Auto: on, the render thread and the recorder thread (4 cores" expected, and main's "Auto: the render thread only (4 cores" shown, so we can see the tester's PC was in the tier that changes.
Raw plan Download plan.json
{
"pass": {
"crash": false,
"fps_mean": {
"min_delta_pct": 5
},
"screenshot": {
"max_diff": 0.1
},
"frametime_p99_ms": {
"max_delta_pct": 10
},
"log_expected_missing": {
"max": 0
}
},
"probe": [
{
"kind": "crash"
},
{
"kind": "frametime"
},
{
"kind": "draws"
},
{
"kind": "log_match",
"expected": [
"vk: Threaded rendering: Auto: on, the render thread and the recorder thread \\(4 cores"
],
"forbidden": []
}
],
"matrix": {},
"schema": 4,
"target": [
{
"cpu": [
"3300x",
"i3 10100",
"i3 12100",
"i3 13100",
"i7 6700",
"i7 6700k",
"i7 7700",
"i7 7700k"
],
"name": "dgpu+cpu-3300x_i3-10100_i3-12100_i3-13100_i7-6700_i7-6700k_i7-7700_i7-7700k",
"tags": [
"dgpu"
],
"max_reports": 2,
"min_reports": 1
},
{
"cpu": [
"1300x",
"3100",
"i5 6500",
"i5 6600k",
"i5 7400",
"i5 7500",
"i5 7600k",
"ryzen 3 1200"
],
"name": "dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200",
"tags": [
"dgpu"
],
"max_reports": 2,
"min_reports": 1
}
],
"summary": "Compare Auto threading on four-core discrete-GPU PCs in Hyrule Field and the Market",
"baseline": {
"ref": "main"
},
"scenario": [
{
"env": {},
"name": "field-market",
"runs": 3,
"step": [
{
"do": "teleport",
"to": "HyruleField_Child"
},
{
"do": "wait",
"map": "HyruleField_Child",
"event": "map",
"timeout_s": 60
},
{
"do": "measure",
"name": "field",
"warmup_s": 10,
"duration_s": 30
},
{
"do": "shot",
"name": "field",
"upload": false,
"compare": "baseline"
},
{
"do": "teleport",
"to": "Market_Child"
},
{
"do": "wait",
"map": "Market_Child",
"event": "map",
"timeout_s": 60
},
{
"do": "measure",
"name": "market",
"warmup_s": 10,
"duration_s": 30
},
{
"do": "shot",
"name": "market",
"upload": false,
"compare": "baseline"
}
],
"start": "save:castle-gate",
"matrix": true,
"settings": {
"vsync": 2,
"frame_rate_cap": 6,
"frame_generation": 0
}
}
]
}
Targets
| Target | Tier | Reports | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| dgpu+cpu-3300x_i3-10100_i3-12100_i3-13100_i7-6700_i7-6700k_i7-7700_i7-7700k CPU "3300x" or "i3 10100" or "i3 12100" or "i3 13100" or "i7 6700" or "i7 6700k" or "i7 7700" or "i7 7700k" | reviewed klimovich008 | none yet | 0/1 pass, 0 running, 2 queued |
| dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200 CPU "1300x" or "3100" or "i5 6500" or "i5 6600k" or "i5 7400" or "i5 7500" or "i5 7600k" or "ryzen 3 1200" | reviewed klimovich008 | none yet | 0/1 pass, 0 running, 2 queued |
Reports
No reports yet. Each tester posts one when its job ends.
Jobs
No tester has a PC for `dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200` (none seen in 14 days): it waits until one signs in.
| Job | Commit | Target | State | Tester | Started | Attempts | Estimate | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
jb_45c595e0a8e74453 | f554451 | dgpu+cpu-3300x_i3-10100_i3-12100_i3-13100_i7-6700_i7-6700k_i7-7700_i7-7700k | queued | — | 0 | No tester online can take it now. | No tester online matches `dgpu+cpu-3300x_i3-10100_i3-12100_i3-13100_i7-6700_i7-6700k_i7-7700_i7-7700k`. | |
jb_bb844baee9e4842f | f554451 | dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200 | queued | — | 0 | No tester has a PC for `dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200` (none seen in 14 days): it waits until one signs in. | No tester online matches `dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200`. | |
jb_57ccdc6c6b1633ed | f554451 | dgpu+cpu-3300x_i3-10100_i3-12100_i3-13100_i7-6700_i7-6700k_i7-7700_i7-7700k | queued | — | 0 | No tester online can take it now. | No tester online matches `dgpu+cpu-3300x_i3-10100_i3-12100_i3-13100_i7-6700_i7-6700k_i7-7700_i7-7700k`. | |
jb_46c048780e729459 | f554451 | dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200 | queued | — | 0 | No tester has a PC for `dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200` (none seen in 14 days): it waits until one signs in. | No tester online matches `dgpu+cpu-1300x_3100_i5-6500_i5-6600k_i5-7400_i5-7500_i5-7600k_ryzen-3-1200`. |